This isn’t meant to usurp anyone else’s postgame thunder, though right now I’m not sure if anyone else plans to post one, but I haven’t seen this “reported” anywhere else around the sphere so I figured I’d throw it up and we could bat it around.
After reading earlier in today’s Sun that Nilsson was getting another chance with the 10/83 duo, I later checked the Oilers official site for their daily podcast only to discover that MacT has decided to throw young Gagner up with with Horcoff and Hemsky duo.
It’s a move I’ve suggested for a little while now, and by suggested I mean that it was necessary to break up with Gagner/Cogliano duo as that combo was bleeding both scoring chances allowed, and not so subsequently surprising, goals against.
Also, this is just guesswork, but when quizzed about how this demotion would affect Nilsson, MacT said he should be OK because he’s going to be playing with two very good players. Now, using deductive reasoning, we’ll assume that the 8-19-51 will be kept together so the two good players that Nilsson will mesh with will either be Cogliano-Penner or perhaps more fittingly,Stoll and Torres. Of course, using logic, we could argue just how good those players are;)
But that’s for another time:)
So, we know MacT believes in the ideas of combos, so no line is safe from the blender. That’s not a process that frustrates me, but it’s one I’m familiar with nonetheless. This means that Gagner may start with 10/83 but who in the hell will he finish with?
In any case, and upon looking at some numbers, I’m not so sure this is a good bet. Gagner’s played the softest minutes of any Oiler and has still come out at -7 at evens. Even though I believe in the ability of the 10/83 duo, isn’t combining your best two players at evens with your worst just an example of cutting off your nose to spite your face?
I think it is if MacT has decided to go power vs power against the Nash line and I don’t think he can use the 10/83 duo in any other fashion.
Overall, the Oilers are -17 at 5-on-5 and the Jackets are even so that gives them a decided edge. If the Nash-Peca-Zherdev line starts carrying the play in a suspected PVP matchup, then MacT will have to switch gears and Gagner will be moved further on down the line, or lines as it were.
What it boils down to is that the way this team was constructed, along with injuries to Moreau and Pisani, it’s created a situation where, as Vic would say, you can only hold so many corks under water at the same time.
Will Gagner’s addition sink the 10/83 duo when it comes to evens? Or is the kid skilled enough to be able to keep up with the young vets and will that lead to a situation where the puck’s in the other end of the ice enough that the defensive zone isn’t a really worry?
This could be interesting if MacT sticks with the matchup for most of the evening.